Brothers On Oak Menu (Update 2026)

Brothers On Oak offers a menu rich with flavors and variety. Here, you can savor hearty burgers like the famed peanut butter burger or dive into the hellhound burger, known for its spicy kick. If you're in the mood for something lighter, their gyros provide a satisfying option. The menu features four standout pizzas: The Portnoy, The Go-To, Walter White, and Brothers Deluxe, each crafted to please the palate. Make sure to choose from their perfectly cooked fries or crispy cheese curds as a side.

At an average price of $10.75, a delicious meal is within reach for everyone.

Pair your food with a selection of craft beers, ideal for a laid-back evening. Brothers On Oak consistently updates their offerings to showcase local brews, making it a cozy stop for both food and drink enthusiasts. Whether it’s game night or open mic, the menu has something for everyone.

Featured Dishes

Gyros
Gyros
The Peanut Butter Burger
The Peanut Butter Burger
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings
The Hell Hound Burger
The Hell Hound Burger
Cheeseburger Fries
Cheeseburger Fries
Chicken Quesadilla
Chicken Quesadilla
General Tao Chicken Bites
General Tao Chicken Bites
Cranberry Surprise
Cranberry Surprise
Blues Brother Burger
Blues Brother Burger
The Greek Freak Gyro
The Greek Freak Gyro
Budweiser Bucket
Budweiser Bucket
Peach Magarita w Don Julio
Peach Magarita w Don Julio
New Beer
New Beer
Gyro Sandwich and Cheese Curds
Gyro Sandwich and Cheese Curds
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Corona
Corona
Bacon Cheeseburger Queso Fries
Bacon Cheeseburger Queso Fries
Brothers On Oak Menu image 1
Brothers On Oak Menu image 2
Brothers On Oak Menu image 3
Brothers On Oak Menu image 4
Brothers On Oak

Brothers On Oak Interior, Food, Ambiance

Stepping into Brothers On Oak feels like entering a welcoming gathering space. The interior combines rustic charm with vibrant energy, perfect for dining or socializing. The wooden accents and warm lighting create an inviting atmosphere that encourages guests to linger and enjoy their meals.

Patrons enjoy an engaging environment filled with live music and an open mic each week, inviting creativity from the community. A pool table in the corner draws groups of friends, adding a competitive edge to the casual dining experience. With great food, a lively ambiance, and a friendly community spirit, Brothers On Oak provides a memorable spot for local hangouts or a bite with friends.

Brothers On Oak

About Brothers On Oak Food and Specialties

Brothers On Oak brings a unique flair to Baraboo's food scene. The star of the menu remains the burgers, particularly the peanut butter burger, which marries sweetness with savory goodness for an unmatched experience. The hellhound burger spices things up for those looking to challenge their taste buds. The pizza options also cater to various preferences, combining quality ingredients and bold flavors. Each dish reflects a commitment to satisfying comfort food, ideal for any time of the week from casual dinners to lively gatherings with friends.

Getting together over plates of food is part of the culture here.

Locals flock to enjoy the specialities, often pairing them with craft beers that highlight the local brewing talent. Don't overlook their gyros, a nod to Mediterranean cuisine, which are sure to delight anyone craving something different. With flavors that resonate with the community and an ambiance that encourages gatherings, Brothers On Oak stands out as a culinary staple in Baraboo.

Brothers On Oak

The commitment at Brothers On Oak revolves around serving excellent food while cultivating a warm community. Every dish prepared embodies the bar’s philosophy of fun and flavor, with specialties like the peanut butter burger capturing attention and appetites alike. The vision remains clear: create a welcoming space where everyone feels at home. Regulars know they can count on great service and consistently delicious meals, solidifying its role as a beloved local venue. With a focus on community and quality, Brothers On Oak continues to thrive, bringing people together, dish by dish.